Costello's Ace Hardware - Long Island
Phone: (631) 243-2220
Fax: (631) 243-2309
FREE shipping to any Costello's Hardware store.

Costello's Hardware - Our Stores

Island Park Newsletter

First Name *
Last Name *
Email *
Spam Trap * Enter the word ACE below.

Island Park
3965 Long Beach Road
Island Park, NY 11558
Phone: 516-431-2500
Fax: 516-431-2544
Manager: John Sutter
John Sutter


Regular Hours
Mon-Fri 7:30-9:00
Sat 8:00-9:00
Sun 8:00-6:00

Holiday Hours
1/1/2015 New Years Day 10:00-4:00
4/5/2015 Easter 8:00-4:00
5/25/2015 Memorial Day 7:30-6:00
7/4/2015 Independence Day 8:00-6:00
9/7/2015 Labor Day 7:30-6:00
11/25/2015 Thanksgiving Eve 7:30-9:00
11/26/2015 Thanksgiving Closed
11/27/2015 Black Friday 7:00-9:00
12/24/2015 Christmas Eve 7:30-6:00
12/25/2015 Christmas Closed
12/31/2015 New Years Eve 7:30-6:00

Our Niche Market
Expert Key Cutting
Computerized Paint Color Matching
Screen and Storm Window Repairs
Automotive Chip Key Cutting
Knife Sharpening
Mower Blade Sharpening
Chainsaw Sharpening
Glass and Acrylic Sheet Cutting
Assembly Available
Lock Re-keying
Special Order over 200,000 items available

I went into the Oceanside store the other day and was helped by a worker named Anthony. He was so helpful and went out of his way to be sure I got all the things I needed. People like Anthony make me feel welcome, and service such as that makes me want to return to your store.
-Terence K.

My wife Kirsti and I have always found friendly, professional and courteous personnel when being at the store. A great number of times we have also requested for assistance and advise and have always received it. We remember soon one year ago when your store opened very soon after Sandy, in the beginning with generator power only helping your customers in need with whatever you had available. Also in those conditions your personnel served very professionally even a number of them obviously dealt with the same catastrophic problems as your customers did. THAT JOB WAS VERY WELL DONE AND DULY APPRECIATED.
Mauri and Kirsti L.

I am writing to compliment two staff members Anthony and Healther who went above and beyond to help me today with a replacement chip key for my car. They were extremely curious, helpful, informative and patient with me. They went as far as making several trips to my car to see if it worked. You are very lucky to have them as employees.
- Lucille G.

Costello's Ace Hardware Store Locator

ACE Rewards Card

Click here to join
ACE Rewards!

Costello's ACE Hardware Is Locally Owned Hardware Store Costello's Ace Hardware stores have been locally owned by Vincent Costello and his family for more than 38 years. The first store opened in Deer Park in 1973, and today the Costello name is recognized for hardware value and service throughout Long Island. Click here to read more about the Costello story.

Costello's Ace is known for a great selection of merchandise and a level of service that exceeds any hardware or home improvement store in the region. As a member of the nationwide Ace Hardware group of independent hardware retailers, Costello's mission is to deliver value-priced products with the highest level of customer care.
Costello's ACE Hardware Is Locally Owned Hardware Store